What Do We Actually Want From AI?

The fear is real, and pointing fingers at each other isn't changing anything. What if creatives started saying what we want instead?

This week I spent ninety minutes as a guest on a podcast talking about AI, creativity, and where humans might be headed next.

It was a big, wandering, philosophical conversation. (The kind I love, and the kind that's hard to sum up afterward.)

One question kept pulling me back. It's the same one I've been dictating into my phone on walks for weeks:

What do we actually want from AI?

I don't hear it asked very often. We talk a lot about what we're afraid of and about who may or may not be using it.

We rarely speak about what we'd ask for.

The fear about AI is valid, and the blaming happening in creative communities isn't going to fix any of it. If writers and artists want a say in what comes next, we have to start saying what we DO want—together.


Why writers and artists are afraid of AI

If you feel queasy about AI, you're not imagining things.

These models were trained on creative work, much of it taken without credit, consent, or pay.

The data centers that run them use enormous amounts of energy, water, and land.

Much of the data labeling behind these models is done by low-paid workers in countries like Kenya, some of them exposed to graphic content they describe as traumatizing.

We're only starting to understand what leaning on these tools does to our thinking and our imaginations.

And no one knows yet which kinds of work AI will replace, or where people fit in whatever comes after.

These are real problems. We need to address each and every one.

And I’m not going to tell you to use the tools anyway so you don't get left behind. That isn't how I see it.


Why AI shaming in writing communities isn’t working

Spend any time in writing communities right now and you'll see it. Someone gets caught using AI, and the pile-on starts. Screenshots. Callouts. Review bombing. Canceled contracts. A bright line between the people in the right and the people in the wrong.

I understand the impulse. It comes from fear, and the fear is real.

I just don't think this is a meaningful path to change. It doesn't get a single writer paid for the work that trained these models. It doesn’t fix data centers, or predatory labor practices.

And it leaves us with only one acceptable answer—shut it all down—when most of us know that isn't happening anytime soon.

I keep thinking about the clothes in my closet.

Most of us know at least some of what goes on behind the fashion industry: exploited labor, pesticide-heavy cotton, worldwide shipping that burns fossil fuels. Millions of us still shop at the worst offenders—those large retailers that sell trendy, affordable clothes.

And if we want to do better, the message is that it's on us, one shopper at a time. Buy used. Wear things longer. Pay more for ethical brands, if you can.

We're applying that same framework to AI. Each artist, alone, is supposed to sort out the ethics of a technology that a handful of companies built and control.


“We are asking too much of individuals in this moment.”

What else is true?

When the fear, anger, and grief come up for me—and they do—I've started asking one question: what else is true?

That question only works after I've dealt with the feelings themselves. For me, that's a long walk, talking into my phone. Meditation. Free-writing. For you it might be therapy, a journal, or your writing group.

Then I try asking this question about something specific. Take the data centers.

It's true that today's data centers use huge amounts of energy and fresh water, and that they can harm the wildlife and the people who live near them.

Is it also true that we can demand sustainable alternatives to fossil-fuel-powered data centers? That we can demand transparency about the infrastructure that AI requires? That there are other ways to power and build this technology, if enough of us ask for them?

Both can be true. Holding them together is what lets me think about what comes next, instead of getting stuck in what's wrong.


AI ethics isn’t an individual problem

For about fifty years we've been told to recycle our plastic. We've seen the islands of garbage in the ocean and read about microplastics in our bodies, and most of us have carried that guilt on our own.

What if the bigger question was always why we make so much plastic in the first place?

We've trained ourselves to be consumers. A few people own and produce; the rest of us buy, and believe we don't have the power to change the systems we don't support. We've also learned to treat positive change as a personal responsibility.

I don't think that's the whole story.

When this many people share the same concerns—and so many of us share these—we get to engage the AI companies, our lawmakers, and our business leaders and say what we want instead.

Some fights are worth having right now. Fair pay for the creative work these models were trained on without consent is one of them. I'm for it.

Over the long run, I'm also interested in the questions beyond "how do we stop this?"

I’m interested in: "what can we build together?"


What creatives want from AI: a starting list

Here's my starting list:

  • AI that's fair to the creators whose work it learned from.

  • AI built with safe working conditions and livable wages for the people who label and train it.

  • AI built in ways local ecosystems and the planet can sustain.

  • AI that's accessible to everyone, beyond the people who can pay the most.

  • AI designed to support life, instead of concentrating wealth in the hands of a few (mostly) men at the top of a few companies.

It's a starting list. I'd love to see yours.

I find that conversation far more exciting than another round of who used what.

How boldly can we imagine this? What would an exciting future in the age of AI look like for the people like us who make things?


“What would an exciting future in the age of AI actually look like for people who make things?”

Something to take back

If you want to try this yourself, here are a few places to start.

  1. Name your fear specifically. Which of these worries you most: the training, the resources, what it does to our thinking, or the work? A named fear is one you can work with.

  2. Ask what else is true. Pick that fear and find one other thing that's also true about it. You don't have to resolve them. Just hold both.

  3. Write your own "what I want from AI" list. Three lines is plenty.

  4. Bring it to one conversation. Your writing group, a friend, or a reply to me.

We're in the middle of something nobody has a map for. I don't either.

What I believe is that a room full of people speaking about what we DO want is a better place to start building, rather than a room full of people pointing at one another.

It's an unsettling time and an exciting one, and each of us has something to bring to it.

—

I'm Jennifer Lewy. I wrote the Firebird Award–winning Game of Paradise trilogy, YA sci-fi set in a world rebuilt around an AI called the NEWRRTH, and I write about staying fully human as AI reshapes creative work.

If you want thoughtful, grounded writing about AI, creativity, and the future of storytelling, join my newsletter. New here? Start with the free prequel, When the Light Came, when you join.

Explore the Game of Paradise series: The One Game | The One Exiled | The One Reborn (January 19, 2027)

Last edited November 19, 2026

Next
Next

The Part I Won't Automate